✔ Backed by: U.S. Preventive Services Task Force · MedlinePlus (National Library of Medicine) · Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) · American Cancer Society · Medicare.gov. Each fact links to its source, and the full list is at the bottom of this post.
Picture this. Your dad turns 55. At his birthday dinner, someone jokes about getting older, and he waves it off: “I’m healthy as a horse. I don’t need anybody poking around.” Everyone laughs. But later, you wonder. Has he ever talked to his doctor about prostate cancer? Have you? Either way, a PSA decision is worth talking through.
September is Prostate Cancer Awareness Month, so it is a good time to talk about it. Prostate cancer is one of the most common cancers in men. Many prostate cancers grow slowly, but some are aggressive [3]. That mix is exactly why this topic can feel confusing. So let’s sit down and talk it through, like two friends at the kitchen table.
Why the PSA decision is a choice, not a rule
Many health checks come with a simple message: get it done. Prostate screening is different. It is a choice you make with your clinician, based on what matters to you.
A PSA test is a blood test that can help find prostate cancer early [2]. But a high PSA does not always mean cancer. Conditions that are not cancer, like an enlarged prostate or an infection, can also raise it [5].
Screening may find cancer early, when it is easier to treat. But it can also lead to false alarms, extra biopsies, and treatment for cancers that would never have caused harm. Treatment can affect bladder and sexual function [1]. If a low-risk cancer is found, ask whether watching it closely, sometimes called active surveillance, could be an option for you.
A PSA decision is a lot to weigh. Some men think, “I want to know, no matter what.” Others think, “I don’t want to go down a road of tests for something that may never hurt me.” Both feelings make sense. Which one sounds more like you?
Who should start the conversation, and when
The U.S. Preventive Services Task Force has guidance for men ages 55 to 69. It says they should make an individual decision about PSA screening with their clinician. It recommends against routine PSA screening for men 70 and older [1]. Guidance can change over time, so ask your clinician what is current.
Some men are at higher risk and may want to start the conversation earlier. That includes Black men and men with a father, brother, or son who had prostate cancer. It also includes men with certain inherited gene changes, such as BRCA [1]. Transgender women and nonbinary people who have a prostate should talk about screening too. Your body’s needs matter, no matter how you identify.
The American Cancer Society also says screening should be an informed choice made with your health care provider. That choice should come after talking about the benefits, risks, and unknowns. It suggests having that talk at age 50 for men at average risk who are expected to live at least 10 more years. It suggests age 45 for men at high risk. This includes African American men and men whose father or brother had prostate cancer before age 65. And it suggests age 40 for men with more than one father or brother diagnosed at an early age [6].
Expert groups do not all use the same ages. That can feel frustrating. But it is one more reason to talk it through with a clinician you trust.
PSA decision questions for the exam room
A lot of men feel awkward bringing this up. It can feel private, or even a little embarrassing. Some worry the talk will lead straight to an exam they dread. Here is a simple way to open the door:
You: “I’d like to talk about prostate cancer screening. Based on my age, race, and family history, what is my risk?”
Then: “What would we do if my PSA comes back high?”
And: “If a low-risk cancer is found, what are my options?”
That last question matters. Knowing the next steps before you test can make the whole choice clearer. What question would you most want answered before deciding?
Signs worth getting checked
“I feel fine” is one of the most common things men say. But most prostate cancers do not cause symptoms early on [4]. That is one reason people talk about screening. Still, see a clinician if you notice:
- Trouble starting to pee, or a weak or stop-and-start stream
- Peeing often, especially at night
- Feeling like your bladder does not empty all the way
- Pain or burning when you pee
- Blood in your urine or semen
- Pain in the back, hips, or pelvis that does not go away
- Painful ejaculation [4]
These signs can be caused by something that is not cancer, such as an enlarged prostate [4]. But only a clinician can sort that out. If a symptom is sudden or severe, get care right away. In an emergency, call 911.
Many men wait on symptoms like these. They figure it is just getting older. Or they feel too embarrassed to say “pee” or “semen” out loud to a doctor. Please don’t let that stop you. Clinicians hear about these things every day. Have you ever put off a visit because the topic felt too personal?
What the test is really like
Here is something that surprises a lot of men. The PSA test is a simple blood draw. It measures PSA, a substance the prostate makes [5]. And screening does not always mean a rectal exam. The U.S. Preventive Services Task Force does not recommend the digital rectal exam as a screening test [5].
Many things can affect your PSA level. These include age, race, some medical procedures, some medicines, an enlarged prostate, and a prostate infection [5]. So tell your clinician about any recent procedures and every medicine you take.
If the PSA test is not normal, your clinician may suggest a biopsy to find out if cancer is there [5]. That can sound scary. But remember, most prostate cancers grow slowly and do not cause health problems [5]. Some are aggressive, which is why a plan made with your clinician matters. Before you test, ask what the next steps would be if your number comes back high.
When cost is the worry
For some men, the real hold-up is money. If that is you, there is no shame in it. Medicare Part B covers a PSA blood test once every 12 months for men over 50. Coverage starts the day after the 50th birthday. You pay nothing for the PSA blood test itself. If your provider does not accept Medicare’s approved amount, you may owe a fee for the doctor’s services, but not for the test. A digital rectal exam is also covered, but you usually pay 20% of the Medicare-approved amount after your deductible [7].
If you have other insurance, call the number on your card. You might say: “Is a PSA screening test covered for me? What would I pay for the visit, and for any follow-up tests if the result is high?”
How to bring it up with someone you love
Maybe this is not about you. Maybe it is your dad, your husband, your brother, or a close friend. You want to say something, but you don’t want to nag. Imagine a talk like this:
You: “Dad, has your doctor ever talked with you about prostate cancer screening?”
Your dad: “Nah. I feel fine. Why go looking for trouble?”
You: “I get that. Most prostate cancers don’t cause symptoms early, though. It’s not about a test today. It’s just a talk with your doctor about whether it makes sense for you. Want me to come along and take notes?”
Notice what that does. It does not push him to test. It invites him to talk. That matters. Some men choose to screen and some do not, and both can be reasonable after a good talk with a clinician. Your job is not to make his PSA decision for him. It is to help him decide well, and then respect his choice.
You can also help gather family health history from relatives. A simple call to an uncle or aunt can turn up something important. And if cancer is found, ask the care team about support groups for patients and partners. What would make it easier for the men in your life to talk about this?
Let’s talk
Now it’s your turn. We would love to hear from you in the comments below.
Did you, or a man you love, choose to get a PSA test or decide to wait? What helped you make that choice?
What words have helped you bring up a “private” health topic with a father, partner, or friend?
What makes it hard for men in your family to talk about their health, and what has helped?
One Tru Step: Ask a family member if any men in your family had prostate cancer, and bring the answer to your next visit.
Sources and further reading
- USPSTF: Prostate Cancer: Screening
- MedlinePlus: Prostate-Specific Antigen (PSA) Test
- MedlinePlus: Prostate Cancer
- CDC: Symptoms of Prostate Cancer
- CDC: Screening for Prostate Cancer
- American Cancer Society: Recommendations for Prostate Cancer Early Detection
- Medicare.gov: Prostate Cancer Screenings
Sources checked October 10, 2026. General education; individual care and coverage questions require an appropriate professional.
Related Health Hubs
Join the conversation 💬
This is your space. Share a tip that helped you, ask the question you have been wondering about, or cheer on someone going through the same thing. Your comment shows up right away, and no account is needed.
Our house rules (they keep this a feel-good spot): Be kind. Stay on topic. Keep it free of religion, politics, and anything hurtful. Comments that break these rules are removed.
Protect your privacy: Use a first name or nickname, and skip full names, phone numbers, and personal health details.
If you or someone you know is in crisis, call or text 988. In an emergency, call 911.